• Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Cheyney Goulding

Cheyney Goulding Solicitors

t: 01483 56 76 76   e: legal@cheyneygoulding.co.uk

alt-text

  • Home
  • About
  • Business Services
        • Commercial Agreements
        • Commercial Property
        • Corporate & M&A
        • Data Protection & Privacy
        • Dispute Resolution & Litigation
        • Employment
        • Finance, Lending & Security
        • Information Technology
        • Intellectual Property
  • Wealth Management
        • Contentious Probate & Will/Inheritance Disputes
        • Court of Protection Advice & Applications
        • Inheritance Tax Planning
        • Later Life Planning & Care Home Fees
        • Powers of Attorney
        • Probate & Estate Administration
        • Residential Property
        • Trusts
        • Wills
  • Team
  • Contact
  • Insights

Business

The Adequacy of the Model Articles of Association for Private Companies Limited by Shares for Companies with Sole Directors

15/11/2022 by Jordan Masters

(All references in this article to any company or companies are to private companies limited by shares)

(any reference to ‘Fore Fitness’ means the case of Hashmi v Lorimer-Wing [2022])

Recently I wrote an article (also published on this website) about articles of association of private companies limited by shares and the High Court case of Hashmi v Lorimer-Wing [2022]; this case established that the ‘Model articles for private companies limited by shares’ (the ‘Model Articles’) are inadequate for enabling a sole director to manage a company because they require at least two directors to manage a company.

Model Article 7 states:

“7.—(1) The general rule about decision-making by directors is that any decision of the directors must be either a majority decision at a meeting or a decision taken in accordance with article 8.

(2) If—

(a) the company only has one director, and (b) no provision of the articles requires it to have more than one director, the general rule does not apply, and the director may take decisions without regard to any of the provisions of the articles relating to directors’ decision-making.”

Model Article 11 states:

“11.—(1) At a directors’ meeting, unless a quorum is participating, no proposal is to be voted on, except a proposal to call another meeting.

(2) The quorum for directors’ meetings may be fixed from time to time by a decision of the directors, but it must never be less than two, and unless otherwise fixed it is two.

(3) If the total number of directors for the time being is less than the quorum required, the directors must not take any decision other than a decision—

(a) to appoint further directors, or

(b) to call a general meeting so as to enable the shareholders to appoint further directors.”

The judge in Hashmi v Lorimer-Wing [2022] ruled, amongst other things, that Model Article 11(2) requires at least two directors to manage a company; this was surprising and contrary to a previous understanding that Model Article 7(2)(a) and (b) prevails over Model Article 11(2), enabling a sole director to manage a company governed by the Model Articles.

However, the recent High Court case of Re Active Wear Ltd [2022] is at odds with Hashmi v Lorimer-Wing [2022].

Re Active Wear Ltd [2022] involved an application to the High Court to declare whether administrators of a company were validly appointed by its sole director or not. One of the judge’s reasons for ruling that the administrators were validly appointed was that Model Article 7(2)(a) and (b) enables a sole director to manage a company. In reaching this decision, the judge in Re Active Wear Ltd [2022] applied the legal principles governing the interpretation of written contracts and ruled that the “unambiguous effect of” Model Article 7(2)(a) and (b) is to enable a sole director of a company governed by the Model Articles to manage that company.  The judge in Re Active Wear Ltd [2022] also ruled that Model Article 7(2)(a) and (b) “prevails over” Model Article 11(2). This is a welcome judgment, as it recognises what is arguably the very purpose of Model Article 7(2)(a) and (b), that is, to accommodate companies which are governed by the Model Articles and have a sole director, so that such sole directors in these circumstances can manage the companies they are directors of “…without regard to any of the provisions of the articles relating to directors’ decision-making” (Model Article 7(2)(b)), such as those contained in Model Article 11.

The judge in Re Active Wear Ltd [2022] addressed the judgment in Hashmi v Lorimer Wing [2022] directly.

In Hashmi v Lorimer-Wing [2022], the company which had a sole director was, in addition to being governed by the Model Articles, also governed by a bespoke Article 16 which stated, amongst other things, that the quorum for a board meeting of the company is two directors, and it amended Model Article 11(2) by imposing some different rules regarding the company’s directors’ meetings.

Whilst upon a reading of the judgment in Hashmi v Lorimer-Wing [2022] it is clear that the judgment applies generally to the interpretation of Model Article 11(2) and Model Article 7(2)(a) and (b) (which I stated in my previous article), the judge in Re Active Wear Ltd [2022] interpreted Hashmi v Lorimer-Wing [2022] as being decided as it was, due to the presence of the bespoke Article 16; the judge in Re Active Wear Ltd [2022] stated that it is: “…clear that the factor dictating the result in Fore Fitness was the existence of Bespoke Article 16.” In relation to the Model Articles, the judge in Re Active Wear Ltd [2022] stated that: “…it cannot have been the intention that they would need to be amended…” in order for Model Article 7(2)(a) and (b) to enable a sole director to manage a company in certain circumstances. Thus, the case of Re Active Wear Ltd [2022] provides legal authority for the legal position that Model Article 7(2)(a) and (b) prevails over Model Article 11(2) and suggests that this legal position may only be displaced if there is a bespoke article in a company’s articles of association which imposes different rules regarding directors’ decision-making.

However, the judge in Re Active Wear Ltd [2022] also stated that Model Article 7(2)(a) and (b) only applies when a company has never had more than one director. Therefore, whilst there is now clear legal authority for Model Article 7(2)(a) and (b) prevailing over Model Article 11(2) when a company has a sole director at the time of incorporation, and has never had more than one director, applying the view of the judge in Re Active Wear Ltd [2022], if a company, governed by the Model Articles, has more than one director and then enters into a state of having a sole director, Model Article 11 will prevail, meaning that at least two directors will be required to manage that company, and a sole director in these circumstances could only appoint further directors or call a general meeting so as to enable that company’s shareholders to appoint further directors in accordance with Model Article 11(3).

It is important to note that Re Active Wear Ltd [2022] and Hashmi v Lorimer-Wing [2022] are both High Court cases and therefore both cases have the same level of legal authority; however, it seems clear that the judgment in Re Active Wear Ltd [2022] will be cited by solicitors when interpreting and applying the terms of the Model Articles, with the judgment in Hashmi v Lorimer-Wing [2022] perhaps being cited in cases where there is a bespoke article within a company’s articles of association which imposes different rules regarding directors’ decision-making.

It will be interesting to see if a case comes before a higher court, such as the Court of Appeal (Civil Division), and a clear judgment which firmly establishes that Model Article 7(2)(a) and (b) prevails over Model Article 11(2) is delivered.

In my previous article, I wrote about the ramifications of the judgment in Hashmi v Lorimer-Wing [2022] and the actions companies with sole directors should take in light of that judgment. In light of the judgment in Re Active Wear Ltd [2022], it appears that it is not necessary for the shareholders of a company governed by the Model Articles with a sole director at the time of incorporation, and which has never had more than one director, to amend that company’s articles of association, nor is it necessary for the shareholders to ratify the decisions of a sole director of that company. However, if a company, governed by the Model Articles, has entered into a state of having a sole director after previously having more than one director, the shareholders of that company should amend that company’s articles of association to make it explicitly clear that that company can be managed by a sole director, and the shareholders of that company should ratify any (purported) decisions made by that company’s sole director in those circumstances.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. If you would like to discuss anything in this article, please get in touch. 

Filed Under: Business

Finance, lending & security

10/01/2023 by

Filed Under: Business, Service feature

The Inadequacy of the Model Articles of Association for Private Companies Limited by Shares for Companies with Sole Directors

05/10/2022 by Jordan Masters

(All references in this article to any company or companies are to private companies limited by shares)

All private companies limited by shares must have articles of association; a company’s articles of association is effectively its ‘rule book’, containing the rules which govern how that company is run. The ‘Model articles for private companies limited by shares’ (the ‘Model Articles’) has been created as a ‘default’ set of articles of association; a company can adopt its own ‘bespoke’ articles of association, adopt the Model Articles with amendments made to it, or adopt the Model Articles without any amendments. A company must register its articles of association with Companies House. If a company does not register any articles of association, the Model Articles will apply to that company.

Section 154 of the Companies Act 2006 makes it clear that a private company limited by shares can have a sole director.

It had been understood that a company could be managed by a sole director with the Model Articles being its articles of association. However, the High Court case of Hashmi v Lorimer-Wing [2022] has established that this is not the legal position. In this case, court proceedings were instigated by Hashmi against Lorimer-Wing and a private company limited by shares of which Lorimer-Wing was the sole director (the ‘Company’), and the Company filed a counterclaim against Hashmi. The Company was governed by an amended version of the Model Articles; the Company’s bespoke Article 16 stated, amongst other things, that the quorum for a board meeting of the Company is two directors, and it amended Model Article 11(2) by imposing some different rules regarding the Company’s directors’ meetings.

Model Article 7, which applied to the Company, states:

“7.—(1) The general rule about decision-making by directors is that any decision of the directors must be either a majority decision at a meeting or a decision taken in accordance with article 8.

(2) If—

(a) the company only has one director, and (b) no provision of the articles requires it to have more than one director, the general rule does not apply, and the director may take decisions without regard to any of the provisions of the articles relating to directors’ decision-making.”

Model Article 11, which applied to the Company insofar as it had not been amended by the Company’s bespoke Article 16, states:

“11.—(1) At a directors’ meeting, unless a quorum is participating, no proposal is to be voted on, except a proposal to call another meeting.

(2) The quorum for directors’ meetings may be fixed from time to time by a decision of the directors, but it must never be less than two, and unless otherwise fixed it is two.

(3) If the total number of directors for the time being is less than the quorum required, the directors must not take any decision other than a decision—

(a) to appoint further directors, or

(b) to call a general meeting so as to enable the shareholders to appoint further directors.”

Hashmi sought for the counterclaim filed by the Company to be struck out by the court. The court struck out the counterclaim. One of the judge’s reasons for striking out the counterclaim was that, as the sole director of the Company, Lorimer-Wing did not have the authority to direct the Company to file the counterclaim. In reaching this decision, the judge applied the legal principles governing the interpretation of written contracts. The judge decided that due to the Company’s articles of association stating that the quorum for directors’ meetings is two (Model Article 11(2) and the bespoke Article 16.1), a minimum of two directors would be required to direct the Company to file a counterclaim; a sole director in these circumstances could only appoint further directors or call a general meeting so as to enable the Company’s shareholders to appoint further directors in accordance with Model Article 11(3). The judge expressly stated in Hashmi v Lorimer-Wing [2022]: “…amendment is required for the Model Articles to permit for a single director to run a company, but consider that such amendment would need to include the deletion of Model Article 11(2).” This is contrary to a previous understanding that Model Article 7(2)(a) and (b) prevails over Model Article 11(2), enabling a sole director of a company governed by the Model Articles to manage that company; the judge in Hashmi v Lorimer-Wing [2022] even recognised: “…Practical Law was more definitive in saying that Model Article 7(2) should prevail over Model Article 11(2)…”

Whilst the judge reached a different conclusion in Hashmi v Lorimer-Wing [2022], arguably, the very purpose of Model Article 7(2)(a) and (b) is to accommodate companies which are governed by the Model Articles and have a sole director at the time of incorporation, or subsequently enter into a state of having a sole director, so that such sole directors in these circumstances can manage the companies they are directors of “…without regard to any of the provisions of the articles relating to directors’ decision-making” (Model Article 7(2)(b)), such as those contained in Model Article 11, and so Model Article 7(2)(a) and (b) should prevail over Model Article 11(2). Whilst the judge reached a different conclusion in Hashmi v Lorimer-Wing [2022], arguably, a company’s articles of association should have to contain an express article stating that that company must have at least two directors, in addition to Model Article 11(2), in order to prevent Model Article 7(2)(a) and (b) enabling a sole director to manage that company.

Whilst the presence of the Company’s bespoke Article 16 might have affected the judge’s reasoning in relation to Model Article 7 and Model Article 11 in Hashmi v Lorimer-Wing [2022], it is clear that this judgment applies generally to the interpretation of Model Article 7 and Model Article 11.

There are multiple ramifications of the judgment in Hashmi v Lorimer-Wing [2022]. If a company is to have a sole director at the time of incorporation, a version of the Model Articles which amends or deletes Model Article 11(2) to explicitly enable that company to be managed by a sole director should be adopted. The shareholders of a company governed by the Model Articles which has a sole director should amend or delete Model Article 11(2) to explicitly enable that company to be managed by a sole director. The shareholders of a company with a sole director, governed by the Model Articles, should ratify any (purported) decisions taken by its sole director to prevent the validity of that director’s decisions being questioned in the future.

This guide is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. If you would like to discuss anything in this article, please get in touch. 

Filed Under: Business

Information technology

10/01/2023 by

Filed Under: Business, Service feature

Intellectual property

10/01/2023 by

Filed Under: Business, Service feature

Shareholders’ Agreements – a short guide

22/04/2021 by Jonny Holgate

What is a Shareholders’ Agreement?

It is common for shareholders of a company to enter into a written agreement with one another which will govern how they will behave in relation to their company. This is known as a Shareholders’ Agreement. The company itself may or may not be a party to this agreement.

It is not compulsory for the shareholders to enter a shareholders’ agreement and it is for each shareholder to enter freely into the contract if he/she decides it is in their interests to do so. Generally though, it is preferable if all shareholders enter into the agreement so that they are all bound by its terms. The importance of entering into the agreement is that it will bind all the parties to the terms and the usual remedies for breach of contract will be available if any of the parties breaches them.

A shareholders’ agreement typically sets out the shareholders’ rights and obligations, regulates the sale of shares in the company, describes how the company will be run, protect minority shareholders, and define how key decisions will be made. Some of these matters will also (or alternatively) be dealt with in the company’s articles of association. We would recommend that you enter into a shareholders’ agreement when you set up your company and issue the first shares. You will also be putting in place the company’s constitution at that time (the articles). Shareholders’ agreements and articles of association should be drafted in such a way as to complement one another ensuring they do not conflict and that between them the internal affairs of the company are regulated in such a way that is fit for purpose and reflects the wishes of the shareholders.

Typical Clauses

Below are a few examples of provisions which would be included in a typical shareholders’ agreement:

  • An undertaking that the company will not amend its articles without the consent of all parties.
  • Similar undertakings regarding changes in capital or share capital structure.
  • Requirements on unanimity among shareholders for major decisions (i.e. the sale of the business).
  • Restrictions on borrowing an offering security over the company’s assets.
  • Agreements regarding further financing for the company.
  • Agreement on dividend policy (i.e. sharing profit).
  • Any disputes between shareholders to be referred to arbitration.
  • Agreement not to compete with the company’s business.
  • Agreement on treatment of intellectual property rights.
  • Provisions dealing with the departure of a shareholder.
  • Provisions for the resolution of deadlock decision-making.

What are the benefits?

A shareholders’ agreement can deal with matters which are personal to the shareholders. Including such personal rights in a shareholders’ agreement means that they become contractually enforceable, whereas this would not be the case if they were included in the company’s articles and reliance placed on the contract under section 33 of Companies Act 2006.

A shareholders’ agreement can provide protection for minority shareholders by reserving certain decisions, such as the ability for the company to issue further shares, which can only be made with the unanimous consent of all the shareholders. 

Also, a shareholders’ agreement being a private contract does not need to be made publicly available. Contrast this with the articles of association of all companies, which must be filed at Companies House and can be read by anyone. The shareholders’ agreement therefore allows for confidentiality.

This guide is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice.  If you would like to discuss anything in this article please get in touch.

Filed Under: Business

‘No Jab, No Job?’ – What does the COVID-19 vaccine mean for employers?

10/02/2021 by Joel Wish

As of writing, over 10 million people in the UK have received a first dose of the coronavirus vaccine.  For some, this shows that some sense of normality may return to the workplace in the not-too-distant future.

But can an employer require his employees to be vaccinated or refuse employment to those who are not?

This seems to be the stance taken by Pimlico Plumbers. The national plumbing company announced they were taking a ‘no jab, no job’ policy and were instructing their lawyers to work on writing the requirement into employment contracts.  However, the matter is not as simple as this.

Below are some thoughts on three key questions employers have regarding the vaccine.

Can employers impose a mandatory vaccination policy to staff?

While this may depend on the workplace and the employee’s role, this will be incredibly unlikely. 

By virtue of the Public Health (Control of Disease) Act 1984, the government have a range of powers to take action to prevent, control or safeguard the public against ‘infection’.  Although, the government is specifically prohibited from requiring anyone to undergo medical treatment, including vaccination.  The government has also reassured the public that they will not enforce any mandatory vaccination programmes.

Considering this, it is highly unlikely UK employers will be looked at favourably should they compel staff to receive vaccinations.

Understandably, employers will likely support their staff in getting the vaccination.  However, some employees may have reasons for refusing the vaccination, i.e. the individual is unable to be vaccinated owing to an underlying health condition or it would be in contravention of their religious or philosophical beliefs.  If an employer’s vaccination policy adversely affects or undermines individuals from a protected group under the Equality Act 2010 (age, sex, race, disability and religion or belief), it will potentially be discriminatory and may encompass high-value compensation claims.

Employers are under a general duty, pursuant to the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974, to take reasonable steps to reduce workplace risks to their lowest practical level.  What this means in a COVID world is that employers should encourage staff to be vaccinated and educate them of the advantages of this towards their health and others in the workplace so that they may make their own informed decision. 

This is a more risk-averse approach that encourages staff to voluntarily take-up of the vaccine. 

Can I discipline or dismiss staff that refuse to be vaccinated?

Again, these situations will require a close analysis of the facts on a case-by-case basis and before taking any such action, it is recommended that you seek legal advice.

Employers are entitled to make ‘reasonable management requests’, which in this case would be asking staff to take up the vaccine.  In cases where it is existing workplace policy to be vaccinated or necessary for someone to responsibly do their job, then an employer may justify disciplinary action if an employee refuses such a request.  An example of this would be where an employee works in the health or care home sectors, it would be reasonable to request a vaccination if this will reduce the risks of passing infection. 

It is much less likely to be a ‘reasonable management request’ where the employee has limited contact with others, is able to work from home or there are alternative measures to reduce the risks of workplace transmission. 

Moreover, employers should be reminded of the need to be flexible with staff and their employees have the right to appeal any dismissal they deem unfair.

Can I refuse employment to individuals who have not been vaccinated?

There is some possibility to this, however, employers still run a major risk of claims, particularly discrimination, being brought against them. 

It may be too early to consider such a measure, especially as the government does not plan on rolling out vaccines for the younger generations until autumn later this year.

This a contemporary, and rather controversial, legal issue. While we await any further government guidance or legislation on the matter, we strongly recommend that employers obtain advice before making any decisions.

Please note, this guide is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice.  If you would like to discuss anything in this article, please get in touch. 

Filed Under: Business

Covid-19 cancellation and suspension of contracts

18/03/2020 by Graham Young

The World has changed.

Worrying about Brexit and freedom of movement seems like a distant memory. The pubs were closed in Dublin on St. Patrick’s day. There is no live sport anywhere in the world. Theaters, bars and restaurants are empty.

New expressions have arrived in the English language; “Self- isolate” is now said more often than “selfie”.

“Force majeure” may also become a significant part of our vocabulary in the coming weeks and months.

Force majeure is the happening of events outside the control of the parties to a contract. For example, this could be natural disasters, the outbreak of hostilities, and, of particular relevance today, epidemics and pandemics. It is usual for parties to provide in a contract that such events will not make the defaulting party liable if they prevent it from performing its obligations. The concept is derived from civil law but is not fully recognised under common law, which means the wording of any force majeure clause is particularly important.

Normally a breach by a party of its obligations under a contract for  non-performance or delayed performance would result in that party being liable to pay the other party the losses that they suffer as a result of the breach. However, if this was caused by an event outside their control and where that circumstance is addressed by a force majeure clause in the contract (which usually includes a list of events) then the party relying on the clause may be able to avoid liability that might have arisen from the breach. In the absence of an express clause, the common law doctrine of frustration may apply.  Frustration only applies in certain restricted circumstances where performance has become impossible. It offers limited relief and remedies to the parties.

If you have any queries about force majeure please contact Graham Young (email: gyoung@cheyneygoulding.co.uk, phone: 01483 796002 or 07967333328).

Cheyney Goulding LLP is a firm of solicitors in Guildford, Surrey. 

This guide is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. 

Filed Under: Business

  • « Go to Previous Page
  • Page 1
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Page 3
  • Page 4
  • Page 5
  • Page 6
  • Page 7
  • Go to Next Page »

Footer Widget Header

 

Footer

Site map

  • Home
  • About
  • Team
  • Insights
  • Careers

© 2026 Cheyney Goulding Ltd

Business Services

Business services

  • Commercial Agreements
  • Commercial Property
  • Corporate & M&A
  • Data Protection & Privacy
  • Dispute Resolution & Litigation
  • Employment
  • Finance, Lending & Security
  • Information Technology
  • Intellectual Property

Wealth Management Services

Wealth management

  • Inheritance Tax Planning
  • Later Life Planning & Care Home Fees
  • Powers of Attorney
  • Probate & Estate Administration
  • Trusts
  • Wills
  • Residential Property
  • Contentious Probate & Will/Inheritance Disputes
  • Court of Protection Advice & Applications

Contact

Phone Number:   01483 56 76 76

Email:   legal@cheyneygoulding.co.uk

More

More

  • Complaints handling policy
  • Prices & services information
  • Privacy policy
  • Privacy notice
  • Cookie policy

Cheyney Goulding Limited is a company registered in England and Wales with registered number 17021359 and VAT number 641411771.
The registered office and principal place of business is at Ward House, 6 Ward Street, Guildford, Surrey, England, GU1 4LH.
Authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA no. 8015202). Our professional code of conduct can be accessed here.
A list of directors is available for inspection at the registered office.

Brand and Website by Supafrank. Photography by Matt Wreford